| Maj 11 | Idag | Maj 13 |
| Liveresultat | Kommande | Avslutade |
| 01:45 | Columbus Crew | 1-2 |
| (ft) | FC Cincinnati | |
| (0-0) | ||
| Columbus Crew | ||
| 38' | Sean Zawadzki | |
| 80' | Rudy Camacho | |
| 89' | Maximilian Arfsten | 1-2 |
| FC Cincinnati | ||
| 34' | Matthew Miazga | |
| 37' | Yuya Kubo | |
| 70' | Obinna Nwobodo | |
| 74' | Kelsy | 0-1 |
| 76' | Luciano Acosta | 0-2 |