| Maj 11 | Idag | Maj 13 |
| Liveresultat | Kommande | Avslutade |
| 01:30 | Toronto FC | 2-3 |
| (ft) | New York City FC | |
| (0-2) | ||
| Toronto FC | ||
| 22' | Federico Bernardeschi | |
| 36' | Sigurd Rosted | |
| 53' | Kevin Long | |
| 56' | Federico Bernardeschi | 1-2 |
| 89' | Raoul Petretta | 2-3 |
| 99' | Federico Bernardeschi | |
| New York City FC | ||
| 23' | Santiago Rodríguez | 0-1 |
| 29' | Alonso Martinez | |
| 44' | Malachi Jones | 0-2 |
| 50' | Malachi Jones | |
| 78' | Andres Perea | 1-3 |
| 99' | Andres Perea | |