| Maj 18 | Idag | Maj 20 |
| Liveresultat | Kommande | Avslutade |
| 01:30 | New York City FC | 2-1 |
| (ft) | New York Red Bulls | |
| (1-1) | ||
| New York City FC | ||
| 3' | Hannes Wolf | 1-0 |
| 32' | James Sands | |
| 64' | Monsef Bakrar | 2-1 |
| New York Red Bulls | ||
| 25' | Cameron Harper | |
| 46' | Cameron Harper | 1-1 |
| 66' | Frankie Amaya | |
| 67' | Sean Nealis | |
| 90' | John Tolkin | |
| 93' | Sean Nealis | |