| Maj 18 | Idag | Maj 20 |
| Liveresultat | Kommande | Avslutade |
| 02:30 | Chicago Fire | 1-3 |
| (ft) | Columbus Crew | |
| (0-1) | ||
| Chicago Fire | ||
| 24' | Rafael Czichos | |
| 45' | Brian Gutierrez | |
| 85' | Carlos Terán | 1-2 |
| 93' | Federico Navarro | |
| Columbus Crew | ||
| 30' | Diego Rossi | 0-1 |
| 55' | Christian Ramírez | 0-2 |
| 88' | Jacen Russell-Rowe | 1-3 |